, and me went to watch Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Naa last evening. The nutshell version is that if [i] you have nothing better to do [ii] there is no other movie playing nearby [iii] desperately need the comfort of a dark theatre for a few laughs, then, go for this movie. If you don’t meet those conditions, all of them, you would end up being disappointed at multiple levels.
I expected [i] much more from Abbas Tyrewala [ii] some difference from an Aamir Khan Production [iii] a much better than this obviously ‘time-pass’ movie
Imran Khan looks cute and since he is expected to be the chocolate boy hero, he does it well enough. There are uncanny patches where his mannerisms echo Aamir (especially that hands-to-the-back-of-head-oh-gosh-me look) but that is expected as well. He tends to chew his words on long sentences and has this odd look-into-the-camera-through-my-eyebrows method of acting in scenes requiring tight close-ups. The role is tailor made for him and he delivers without hamming. Nothing sensational.
Genelia D’Souza overacts, whines, rolls eyes and generally annoys one with that accented Hindi. The overbearing ‘chh’ sound in each word that is supposed to be ‘ch’ might be due to her Telugu film stints, but she should have worked on it. She acts her role. Just about. Nothing to rave home about.
Cameos or short acts that just make you sit up and watch the movie – Ratna Pathak Shah, Naseeruddin Shah (as the dead dad in picture frame who talks with Ratna the mom), Sugandha Garg (who plays the wordly wise Shaleen) and Nirav Mehta (as Jiggy of the surprise birthday party fame). Prateik Babbar gets media attention for being ‘broody and silent’ but there isn’t enough meat in his role to do anything. And then of course there is Arbaaz Khan and Sohail Khan (in a double bill comedy act that’s sure to make you roll) and Paresh Rawal (as the Inspector Waghmare). If small acts made a good movie, then you need good folks doing them – this movie has a few of them.
The story is as old as they come. Boy and girl are best pals in a group of buddies in college. The world and it’s uncle think they are in love and should marry. They don’t see each other that way. They meet their individual ‘potential loves’ and then waste 40 minutes of movie time figuring out that it isn’t meant to be. Some skirmishes later they dramatically re-unite at airport and Imran sings the ‘special song’ for his love (that’s where the title of the movie comes from).
Feel like you have seen the movie already ? You bet. It is just a bit more polished and well executed than the earlier versions of the same story. Music is good, the dialogues reflect the way folks their age talk. And that’s about it.